Thursday 28th March 2024,
The Hoop Doctors

Is Jermaine O’Neal the missing piece to a Colangelo masterpiece in Toronto?

Bryan Colangelo | 2009 Toronto Raptors

August 20, 2008 – Dr. Browntorious

Yesterday I read a great Sports Illustrated post by Ian Thomsen on Jermaine O’Neal and his summer rehab efforts in Las Vegas. If you are even remotely a J.O. or Raptors fan, you definitely have to check it out as it will get you more than just a little excited for the upcoming NBA season. For me, it’s not so much that i’m either a Raptors or J.O. fan, but more that i’m a Bryan Colangelo fan. The guy is an absolute genius when it comes to putting the right mix of players on a roster for a team to thrive. The speed at which he has turned the Raptors franchise around, back to respectability has been nothing short of miraculous.

What I found most interesting about the Sports Illustrated preview of Jermaine O’Neal for next season however was Colangelo’s comments on the mindset of Jermaine O’Neal and how this played into his decision to make a move for O’Neal. Colangelo had this to say:

“He is extremely motivated right now to answer any questions about his health, his attitude and who he is as a basketball player. I can’t think of a better mental or emotional state to find a player in.”


While many other NBA General Managers and scouts are out there evaluating talent based on their skill, health, and ability to fill a gap in their current roster, Bryan Colangelo is taking it to another level by evaluating a player’s personality, emotional state, and psyche as these factors are hugely important to how well a player will mesh with a team’s current personnel and team philosophy. Regardless of the fact that Jermaine O’Neal is only 30 years old, he has seemingly been through it all during his career. From being the leader and focal point of a team that had an NBA leading 61 win season, to being suspended and charged for punching a fan, to being involved in legal issues away from basketball, to playing injured, to rehabbing from knee surgery. But there is one thing O’Neal has not done, and that is win a championship. It’s for this reason that Colangelo felt that not only does O’Neal have the skill set to fill a couple major needs of the Raptors (defense and rebounding), but he also has the drive and motivation to prove all his recent nay sayers wrong, and show he has a lot left in the tank, and he can be a big factor for a winning franchise once again.

What I always found humorous when Colangelo first arrived in Toronto, was the notion developed by the mainstream media that his goal was to somehow re-create an Eastern Conference version of the 2005-06 Phoenix Suns with the Raptors roster. Essentially a run and gun offense, where the ultimate goal was to outscore your opponent with little regard for defense. Instead, Colangelo made moves to bring in pass-first heady players, and spot-on perimeter shooters that really wanted to play basketball “the right way” (as Coach Larry Brown always says). The only problem with their defense (a major one however) up until O’Neal’s arrival has been, Chris Bosh could not be in two places at once, and therefore the team couldn’t defend at the rim. Couple that with the fact that the Raptors were one of the weaker defensive rebounding clubs among the Eastern Conference playoff teams, and you have a very large hole that needs filling. In comes Jermaine O’Neal.

After telling you how I disagreed with the thought that Colangelo is attempting to recreate the Phoenix Suns in the East, my thoughts on the current roster make-up of the Raptors now creates a very glaring internal irony for me. If you look fairly closely at the player skill sets and how they play, you will actually notice a pretty strong similarity between the current roster of the Raptors and the make up of the Phoenix Suns. While I used to laugh at the notion that Colangelo would be re-creating an Eastern Conference version of the 2005 Phoenix Suns, he may just have re-created in Toronto a similar style and roster to the 2008-09 Phoenix Suns. Here is a quick look at what i’m thinking:

Center: Jermaine O’Neal, Shaquille O’Neal

Both players have been the subject of criticism that their careers are in decline. However, regardless of how well either one plays in comparison to 4 or 5 years ago, no one will deny they are game changers on defense through intimidation in the paint and strong defensive rebounding abilities.

Power Forward: Chris Bosh, Amare Stoudemire

Both Bosh and Stoudemire are freaks of nature when it comes to their ability to score in a variety of ways regardless of their size. It is still uncommon to see power forwards put the ball on the floor with such ease, have deep range on their jump shots, and yet still dominate opponents in the post with footwork when a bucket is needed. Both Bosh and Stoudemire not only can create their own shot, but have great hands in traffic when on the receiving end of passes from teammates.

Small Forward: Jamario Moon, Matt Barnes

Jamario moon has made a name for himself in the NBA for being a high flyer. But the real Cinderella story surrounding Moon is predicated on his ability to rebound, hustle, defend, and do whatever else is necessary to help the team win. These skills and attributes of Moon are exactly the reason the Phoenix Suns signed Golden State Warriors forward Matt Barnes. Barnes has coupled his athleticism and speed with a toughness and grit on defense that helps him bring similar traits to the table as Jamario Moon. They both are excellent defenders, shot blockers, and rebounder’s, but the biggest offensive similarity is their ability to hit the open jump shot up to and including 3-pt range.

Shooting Guard: Anthony Parker, Raja Bell

Probably two of the more unsung heroes on their respective squads. These two guys are given the job night in and night out of defending the oppositions top perimeter scorer. How would you like to be in charge of shutting down Kobe Bryant, TMac, Lebron James, or DWade? What amazes me most about these two similar role players, is their ability to still have something in the tank for offense. You rarely see these two guys take “bad shots”, as they have excellent discipline and sweet strokes from the perimeter.

Point Guard: Jose Calderon, Steve Nash


It’s really hard to compare anyone to Steve Nash. Let’s face it, there is nobody like him and there probably never will be. But if someone put a gun to my head and told me to name a player most like Steve Nash, i’d undoubtedly throw out the name Jose Calderon. Both players are amazing passers and ball handlers, but unselfish to a fault. And what is that fault? The fact that these guys are such high percentage shooters for a guard, it makes it almost too bad that they don’t shoot more often. However, both possess a special trait of just somehow knowing when their team needs a scoring spark and then they aren’t shy about getting the job done. Stoudemire and Bosh might be the scoring leaders on their respective teams, but everything on offense starts and finishes with Nash and Calderon.

I don’t presume to know who the eventual starters will be on either squad heading into the new season, and I realize that there are many differences in some of the other players that fill out these rotations like Andrea Bargnani, Grant Hill etc. But the roster similarities are enough to have me admiring the genius of Colangelo and Kerr in building a well rounded squad for success in the ‘New NBA’. This next season or two for the Raptors will determine whether this masterpiece of Colangelo’s will have us all calling him “MiColangelo“.

Like this Article? Share it!